Blog

By Steve Cuffari, LMFT | In Touch Individual & Family Counseling — Tustin, CA

Every family argues. That part is normal — and honestly, expected.

What’s not normal is feeling like you’re having the same fight on repeat — same trigger, same explosion, same retreat to separate corners. If that’s your family right now, here’s what 25 years in this work has taught me: love is rarely the problem. The missing piece is almost always a framework for how to manage disagreements.

After more than 25 years working with families in Orange County, I’ve seen this pattern play out hundreds of times. And I’ve seen it change — when families stop trying to win their conflicts and start trying to solve them together. That shift is exactly what Collaborative Problem Solving (CPS) makes possible.

Related Reading: 5 Family Communication Tips That Build Trust and Reduce Conflict

Quick Answer — What Is Collaborative Problem Solving for Families? Collaborative Problem Solving (CPS) is an evidence-based approach that replaces punishment and power struggles with a structured 3-step process: understand the concern → define the problem → build a solution together. It works because it treats conflict as a skills gap, not a discipline problem. Research shows it produces lasting behavior change in children, teens, and family systems.

What Is Collaborative Problem Solving?

Collaborative Problem Solving is an evidence-based approach developed by Dr. Ross Greene, a clinical psychologist and former Harvard faculty member. It’s been used widely in schools, clinical settings, and family therapy for decades — and for good reason. It works.

The foundational idea behind CPS is deceptively simple: challenging behavior happens because a person lacks the skills to handle a particular demand or situation in that moment — not because they’re choosing to be difficult.

That reframe alone changes everything.

Instead of asking “How do I get my child to comply?” or “Why does my teenager always have to fight me on this?”, CPS shifts the question to: “What’s getting in the way here, and how can we figure this out together?”

This isn’t about letting kids — or anyone — off the hook. It’s about understanding that behind almost every conflict is an unmet need or an underdeveloped skill. And you can’t punish your way to a skill. You have to build it.

As a Licensed Marriage and Family Therapist (LMFT #44845) who has extensive  training in Collaborative Problem Solving at the Trainer of Trainers level, and who works with families dealing with everything from everyday communication breakdowns to the added complexity of ADHD and neurodivergence, I use CPS regularly in my Tustin practice because it produces real, lasting results — not just temporary compliance.

Why Punishment and Avoidance Make Family Conflict Worse

Here’s what I see in my office, over and over: families arrive thinking the problem is their teenager’s attitude, or their partner’s stubbornness, or their own inability to stay calm. The real problem is almost always the strategy they’re using — not the people using it.

Most families default to one of two patterns when conflict arises: power-based responses (punishments, ultimatums, consequences) or avoidance (ignoring the issue and hoping it resolves itself). Neither addresses the underlying problem. Both erode trust.

Here’s the neuroscience behind why: when conflict escalates — when voices rise, emotions flood, and the situation starts to feel threatening — the brain’s survival system takes over. The prefrontal cortex, the part responsible for reasoning, empathy, and problem-solving, essentially goes offline. You’re no longer in a conversation. You’re in a threat response cycle.

I see this show up in families as what I call the Distance-Isolation Cascade — a physiological pattern where repeated unresolved conflict quietly chips away at emotional safety and intimacy. Each argument that ends without resolution adds another layer of distance. Over time, family members stop bringing problems to each other because they’ve learned it won’t lead to anything productive.

Punishments and lectures don’t interrupt this pattern. They reinforce it. What breaks the cycle is restoring felt safety — and that has everything to do with how you approach conflict, not just the words you use.

The 3 Steps of Collaborative Problem Solving

CPS is structured around three steps. They’re straightforward on paper, but like any skill, they take real practice — especially when emotions are running high. Here’s how each step works.

Step 1: The Empathy Step

The Empathy Step is where most families want to skip ahead — and where CPS lives or dies.

Before you present your concern, before you problem-solve, before you do anything else, your job is to understand the other person’s perspective. Not to agree with it. Not to fix it. Just to understand it.  The empathy step begins with a simple invitation to understand others’ perspectives.  

With a child or teenager, this might sound like: “I’ve noticed you’ve been really upset when it’s time for homework. What’s going on?” Then you stop talking and actually listen. Next, you reflect back and try to summarize what you hear. Doing so ensures that the message that was sent, is actually the message you heard.  As an example, “It sounds like you like your teacher, but you can’t stand doing math homework.  Did I hear you accurately?”  To ensure that you are tracking with the speaker, you ask follow-up questions. And during this reflective listening exchange, you stay curious instead of reactive.

This step feels slow, especially when you’re frustrated. But it’s non-negotiable. A person who doesn’t feel heard will not engage in problem-solving — they’ll dig in, shut down, or escalate. And that holds for kids, teenagers, and adults.

Step 2: Define the Problem

Once you genuinely understand the other person’s concern, it’s time to ask the speker if you can add your perspective to the table.

It’s important to note that this is not the moment to unload every grievance you’ve been storing. It’s the moment to state your concern clearly and concisely, using calm, non-accusatory language.

Something like: “Here’s my concern — when homework doesn’t get done before dinner, you seem to get pretty stressed, , and I’m concerned how that impacts our  family.”

At this stage both sets of concerns are on the table.  . Notice, nobody is  winning and nobody is losing. Not one concern is more valid than the other. Just two real perspectives on the same situation.

In my experience, this is where most families derail. They state their concern as a verdict — “You never help around here” — rather than a specific, observable concern. They loop in past grievances. They make it about poor choices, solutions that will fix the problem, and sometimes the other’s character flaws:  unwilling, unhelpful, ect. . Staying focused on only sharing your concerns without adding solutions is a discipline. And the only ingredient that  makes the third step possible.

Step 3: The Invitation Step

Now, and only now, do you move into problem-solving. And here’s the part that surprises most parents I work with: you don’t generate the solution. You invite it.

“If I heard you correctly, your concern is doing what you describe as boring and useless homework, and my concern is how the stress of not doing it before dinner impacts our family.  So, I’m wondering if there’s a way to address both your concerns and mine.  Do you have any ideas?  

This is collaborative, not consultative. You’re not asking for input and then deciding anyway. You’re genuinely building a solution together — one that has to address both concerns to count. You coming to mutually agreeable solutions that meet everyone’s concerns.  

Solutions that only solve one person’s concern won’t stick. A child who does not agree with an outcome  has no investment in it. But a teenager who helped design the solution? They’ll surprise you with how reliably they follow through.

CPS at a Glance

A Real Family Case: CPS in Action

The case I’m about to describe isn’t unusual — I see versions of it regularly in my Orange County practice. But it captures exactly why CPS works when nothing else has.

A family comes to see me — parents exhausted, a 13-year-old son who’s completely shut down. He refuses to do anything around the house, gives one-word answers, and the whole household is tense. They’ve tried grounding him, taking his phone, and having serious talks. Nothing works. By the time they call me, they’re convinced the relationship is broken.

When we slow things down and apply the CPS framework, something shifts. In the Empathy Step, we learn that the son feels as though rules are just handed down to him without any input. He doesn’t feel like his perspective matters. The parents had no idea — they thought he just didn’t care about contributing.

Once both concerns are on the table — his need to feel respected and have some autonomy, their need for the household to function better — they work out a solution together. He picks which responsibilities he takes ownership of each week. The parents get the help they need. He gets a sense of agency.

It’s important to note that compliance didn’t improve because of pressure. It improved because he had a voice. That’s the difference!

Seeing yourself in this story? If your family feels stuck in a similar pattern, a free clarity call is a good first step — no commitment, just a conversation.

Practical Tips for Families Starting Out with CPS

Most families don’t need to wait for a therapy appointment to start shifting things at home. These are the principles I give families in session — and they work just as well around your kitchen table.

Pick the right moment. CPS requires a calm enough nervous system to actually work. If emotions are already escalating, table the conversation. A simple “I really want to figure this out with you — it think it’s best if we talk in 20 minutes?” is not avoidable. It’s a strategy.

Get curious before you get firm. Before reacting to a behavior, pause and ask yourself what might be driving it. Odds are, he’s not giving you a hard time, he’s actually having a hard time.  A child who melts down every Sunday night might be anxious about the upcoming school week rather than acting in defiance. That distinction changes your entire response.

Lead with the Empathy Step, every time. It’s tempting to skip straight to sharing your concern, especially when you’re tired and frustrated. Resist that urge. The empathy step is what makes the whole process work.

Validate feelings before redirecting behavior. Saying “I can see you’re really frustrated right now” before you address the behavior is not a weakness — it’s the most efficient path to a productive conversation. It keeps the prefrontal cortex online. If you want to go deeper on why this matters, my guide on communication problems in relationships explains the underlying patterns in detail.

Make it a regular practice, not just a crisis response. Families who integrate CPS into their daily conversations find success — not just when things blow up. A brief weekly family check-in, where anyone can raise a concern using this structure, can prevent larger conflicts well before they start.

Be patient with yourself and your family. CPS is a skill set, not a switch you flip. The first few attempts feel clunky — that’s expected. What you’re building is a new relational pattern, and patterns take repetition. If you’d like support building this inside your family, my approach to family counseling is built around exactly these principles.

When Family Conflict Needs Professional Support

CPS is something any family can learn, and I encourage families to start practicing these steps on their own. But there are situations where working with a licensed family therapist can significantly accelerate the process and help families navigate dynamics that are hard to navigate without support. 

In my practice, I integrate CPS with Emotionally Focused Therapy (EFT) — an approach backed by over 30 years of research showing that 70% of couples and families move from distress to full recovery.

Consider reaching out if your family is experiencing:

• Recurring conflicts that never fully resolve despite good intentions
• A child or teenager who feels completely unreachable or has shut down
• Communication challenges complicated by ADHD, anxiety, or other diagnoses
• Co-parenting tension that’s affecting the children
• A significant rupture in trust — whether between parents, between a parent and child, or both
• A general sense that everyone is walking on eggshells at home

At my family counseling practice in Tustin, I work with families throughout Orange County — including Irvine, Costa Mesa, Newport Beach, and Santa Ana — and I offer online therapy for families across all of California. Whether you come in person or connect virtually, the work is the same: helping your family find a path from conflict to connection.

Your Family Doesn’t Have to Stay Stuck

Conflict in families isn’t evidence that something is broken. It’s evidence that real people — with different stress thresholds, different histories, different needs — are in close proximity and trying to make it work. That’s just family life.

What CPS gives you is a repeatable way through the hard moments. Not a magic fix. A structure. One that slows things down just enough for everyone to actually be heard — and for solutions to get built together rather than handed down from whoever has the most authority in the room.

I’ve watched this change families that came in convinced they were out of options. If you’re in that place, I’d genuinely like to talk. A free clarity call takes 20 minutes. No commitment. Just a conversation to see if working together makes sense.

Schedule Your Free Clarity Call →

The information in this article is educational and does not constitute clinical advice. If you or your family are experiencing a mental health crisis, please contact a licensed mental health professional or dial 988 (Suicide & Crisis Lifeline).

Steve Cuffari, LMFT (#44845) is a Licensed Marriage and Family Therapist and the founder of In Touch Individual & Family Counseling in Tustin, CA. A former psychology professor and ordained minister, Steve is a Trainer of Trainers in Collaborative Problem Solving and practices Emotionally Focused Therapy (EFT). He has worked with individuals, couples, and families in Orange County for over 25 years. He serves clients in-person in Tustin and online throughout California.