Restoring Trust After Infidelity: 3 Vital Steps
hands of a couple intertwined, showing their wedding rings. here are the steps in restoring trust after infidelity

Share on

Meet Maria and John, who were dealing with infidelity in their marriage.  They entered my office a year after John met a woman on social media and developed a sexual relationship with her.  Like many spouses who’ve been devastated by infidelity, Maria told me that she learned about John’s cheating and adultery less than a week ago when she received a phone call from John’s mistress. 

Maria had confronted John about his social media comments to women several weeks earlier.  Yet, he denied it, saying, “My insecurities were raging again.”  She revealed several other occasions where John was dismissive about why he arrived so late from work.

Armed with the certainty John’s mistress revealed, Maria felt a storm of betrayal, disbelief, and pain at John’s infidelity, which left them adrift in a sea of uncertainty, making it difficult to turn toward each other.  Thankfully, despite Maria’s unbearable pain, they found the courage to seek guidance to try and mend their fractured relationship. 

During that meeting, I inquired about their ten years of marriage and learned about their love, loyalty, and devotion to each other.  I learned about their ups and downs, the good and tough times, and how job changes and the stress of having three beloved children had engulfed them through the years. 

As I listened to Maria express her devastation, she started wiping the tears from her troubled face… asking, “Why… Why… would John do such a thing?”  Her pain… and their reason for calling me…  became obvious when she uttered the following statement:.  “I don’t know… I don’t know if we can ever put the pieces back together again!” 

As John gently clutched Maria’s hand, the tears flowed while she uttered, “I don’t know if I can ever trust him again… I’ve lost complete trust in him… his words… and his actions!  How do we recover from this disastrous storm?”

The Initial Shock: Confronting Marital Infidelity

In the wake of infidelity, that’s the biggest question I hear from spouses dealing with the unbearable pain that follows:  “Will I ever be able to trust my spouse again?”  

Our meeting was a telling moment:  Maria and John knew they needed to improve their communication and heal. Otherwise, divorce or a lifetime of heartbreak, pain, and loneliness would consume them! Their story reflects the journeys of so many couples who face infidelity–a path involving pain, healing, and the gradual rebuilding of trust.

Thankfully, for more than two decades, I’ve relied on a proven approach to working with couples where trust was torn apart by infidelity.  The strategies I share are pulled from these real-world successes and backed by the latest findings in couple’s therapy. 

Although it takes courage and hard work, I’ve had numerous couples call me years later, hand me Christmas cards, or send heartfelt emails sharing how they had overcome those difficult times, found their way to better communication, and enjoyed a more secure and lasting bond again! Many have shared, “Our trust is stronger, more transparent, and more comforting than ever.”

As with all couples, the revelation of an affair can hit with the force of a tidal wave, engulfing you in a flood of emotions like shock, anger, and betrayal. These initial reactions are raw and real.

It’s vital to allow yourself to feel these emotions and acknowledge their pain and confusion. This is not the time for hasty decisions or forced forgiveness. Although it’s not easy, it’s a time for reflection to grasp the full impact of the betrayal on your life and your family.

Therapy: A Lifeline for Couples

Above all, trying to mend the rifts of infidelity alone can feel like navigating a raging storm without a compass, often leading to deeper hurt and unresolved feelings. It’s best not to carry this burden alone because unraveling the complex emotions of infidelity and betrayal is daunting.

According to the American Association for Marriage and Family Therapy, 50% of couples who engage in professional counseling after incidents of infidelity report a significant improvement in their relationship’s trust levels within a year.

Therefore, a good therapist familiar with this landscape can provide a structured path to address the hurt and help you begin restoring trust after infidelity. Think of it as leverage. Seeing a skilled therapist can help both partners generate understanding, healing, and hope with more confidence and less effort.

Step 1: Re-establishing Emotional Safety

So, how do you rebuild trust after heartbreak?

The foundation of any healing process is re-establishing a sense of emotional safety.  It’s pivotal because the psychological impact of infidelity goes beyond initial shock. Survivors often experience phases akin to post-traumatic stress, where triggers can evoke intense emotional responses.  As a result, couples must find the courage to create an environment that acknowledges these emotional triggers… and do so without judgment, which is not easy.

In therapy, we often see patterns of grief and loss similar to mourning the death of a relationship as it was known before. This grief process is crucial and must be navigated carefully, as it involves predictable stages of denial, anger, bargaining, depression, and acceptance. 

This means creating an environment where open, honest communication is encouraged and essential. While in this “safe zone,” both partners must feel heard and understood to share their vulnerabilities—without fear of judgment or reprisal.

In this safe space, you can begin to process infidelity, address the hurt, and start laying the bricks of trust anew.  However, without a safe space, partners typically remain stuck, hurt, and resentful of each other, only making things worse.

Moving Beyond Fear: Fostering Security and Understanding_

Emotional safety goes beyond the absence of conflict; it’s about building a relationship where fears and hopes can be shared openly. This requires a significant investment of time and empathy, especially after an affair. For today’s busy couples, it means carving out moments of peace amidst the chaos, reconnecting with your partner, and rediscovering emotional safety and comfort.

Emotional Safety Requires Being Vulnerable After Infidelity

After infidelity, becoming vulnerable again can be a daunting risk. Yet, in these moments of openness and honesty, the groundwork for rebuilding trust is laid. This means being brave enough to express your fears and let your partner see your true self, despite the pain.  Take note. This act of vulnerability is a potent catalyst for healing the deep wounds inflicted by infidelity. 

Step 2: Understanding the Underlying Emotional Needs

As emotional safety is re-established, it’s time to focus on what lies beneath. Infidelity always has an emotional landscape that needs to be identified and understood by both partners. After conducting therapy for more than 22 years, I’m convinced that infidelity is always a symptom of deeper, unaddressed emotional needs. In other words, affairs, betrayal, or infidelity don’t just happen out of the blue.  They are the product of unresolved and unmet expectations.

Through the years, my clients have taught me that infidelity goes far beyond physical attraction. It’s always about the deeper emotional dissatisfaction and unmet needs between partners.

That’s why understanding the emotional landscape of infidelity is crucial to the healing process. Although challenging, it involves a journey into the heart of your relationship to uncover the emotional voids that may have contributed to the affair.

Additionally, this step is about introspection and honesty, recognizing your true and authentic unmet or unrecognized needs. Next, it’s about understanding how those unmet needs influence—and continue to influence—you both each day.

The Emotional Whys Behind Marital Infidelity

Hence, as we look beneath the surface of our everyday lives, it’s important to understand the underlying emotional needs in our relationships. This step is key because betrayal rarely occurs in isolation. Instead, it stems from basic, unmet emotional needs to feel understood and accepted. These might include a deeper emotional connection or wanting to discuss money, sex, or parenting without all the drama. Acknowledging and understanding these emotional needs are crucial for healing and mending, offering a chance to strengthen and fortify your relationship.

Communicating Unmet Needs: A Pathway to Clarity

Indeed, understanding each other’s underlying emotional needs means voicing the unsaid. Simply put, it requires using words to express your true and authentic feelings to each other.

Yes, discussing unmet needs is challenging, particularly after an affair, while balancing the demands of life. However, clear communication about these needs is essential for bridging the emotional gap within your relationship. Doing so ensures that both partners feel valued and heard, creating a mutual understanding that can lay the foundation for a renewed and stronger bond.

Step 3: Rebuilding Trust and Connection

As we understand each other’s underlying emotional needs, a natural shift to restoring trust and connection begins. (Assuming the ultimate goal of healing from infidelity is restoring trust and rebuilding the emotional bond between partners).

My experience with couples has taught me that rebuilding trust requires two key ingredients:

  1. Time… and plenty of it.
  2. Predictable behavior.

On the one hand, time can help heal this deep wound. On the other hand, predictable behavior rebuilds the crumbled trust. Rest assured that each consistent, loving (and predictable) action is a precious step toward a future where trust and love can bloom anew.

As a result, this process involves rekindling the emotional intimacy that may have faded, dedicating time and effort to understanding each other’s true and authentic needs, and working together to validate each other as you rebuild trust.

Overall, it’s no secret that this journey requires patience, commitment, and a deep-rooted willingness to forgive and move forward together.  Yet, the reward can be a more secure and lasting bond for life!

Healing Together

Restoring trust after infidelity is a journey of emotional reconnection, and it’s not for the faint of heart, especially after an affair. That’s why finding a therapist after an affair is crucial. A good therapist will specialize in helping distressed couples rebuild their trust and emotional bonds, guiding them through understanding and healing the deep-rooted issues that activated the infidelity.

Therapy can help set the stage for you and your partner to embark on a journey of emotional reconnection. It can empower you to understand each other’s emotional responses, foster deeper empathy, and facilitate the creation of new, positive interactions.

Best of all, it can transform your relationship’s narrative from betrayal and pain to renewed understanding, connection, and hope.

Creating New Memories: The Essence of Emotional Bonding

Thus, rebuilding the emotional bond means creating new, positive emotional experiences together. These moments become the building blocks of a renewed relationship. It could be as simple as shared laughter over a private joke, a quiet conversation, or a meaningful gesture that shows care and understanding. Each of these experiences weaves a new thread in the fabric of your relationship, helping to heal the scars of infidelity and restore the precious bond that was strained.

From Betrayal to Renewed Trust: Embracing the Future

Restoring trust after infidelity is not just about looking back and repairing what was broken. It involves having the courage to embrace a future together, strengthened by the trials you’ve overcome.

It’s no secret that while balancing family, life, and love, this journey might seem overwhelming. However, remember that each step forward is a step towards a stronger, more resilient, and deeply connected relationship.

With patience, empathy, and commitment, your bond of trust can be rebuilt, leading to a deeper, more meaningful connection than ever before.

You are not alone!

Regardless of the challenges in your relationship, I want you to feel empowered with the tools and skills you need to free yourself from those destructive conversations and enjoy a more secure and lasting bond for life! Couples therapy and marriage counseling in Tustin can help.

I would love to be your guide if you want a clear path to intimacy. Contact me today to learn how couples therapy can help.

About the Author

Picture of Steve Cuffari

Steve Cuffari

For over 20 years, Steve Cuffari has been an ordained minister, assistant college professor of psychology at vanguard university, and a therapist committed to helping individuals, couples, and educators learn how to put an end to destructive conversations so they can build secure and lasting relationships... More about Steve →


Got Questions?

Thank You!

You’ve been added to our mailing list and will now be among the first to hear about our latest news and events.

Thank You!

We have received your message and we will get back to you as soon as we can.